Sunday, January 1, 2012
New Year, New Adventures
Saturday, November 21, 2009
The "Cold Turkey" Approach?
Thank you to Miraculous Multiples, a support and social group for parents of twins, triplets, and more in Crystal Lake, Illinois. I met with the group this week as a guest speaker, and we discussed questions regarding all aspects of raising twins. Among other issues, we talked about instilling good sleep habits, keeping the family peace from a discipline standpoint, and various toddler habits that, while frustrating, are developmentally normal.
At the meeting, one of the members and I talked about how to help her 11 month-old boy-girl twins sleep through the night. A few weeks ago, the mother was concerned her daughter was getting sick and offered a 2 am bottle– unfortunately, they fell into a pattern with this new overnight feeding, and the bottle was disrupting her and her room-sharing twin brother’s sleep. I explained that a healthy, normally developing 11 month-old does not require overnight feedings, and the new habit has created a ‘learned hunger’ at a very inconvenient time. Imagine if we, as adults, woke up at 2 am to eat a bowl of cereal– after a few nights of this, we’d feel hungry at that time, even though we do not physiologically need a 2 am bowl of cereal.
Should Mom slowly reduce the ounces offered each night over a week, or simply go “cold turkey” and abruptly stop the bottle? With many parenting questions, there is no one “correct” answer. Sometimes the slower, more gradual approach can be a kinder, gentler way to go, however it can prolong the transition out over a longer stretch of time. Another analogy is removing a sticky bandage. Should you rip the band-aid off quickly (it hurts, but it’s over faster), or slooowly remove it, prolonging the pain?
In the case of this healthy, normally developing 11 month-old, it is appropriate to eliminate overnight bottles– the cold turkey approach may result in lots of tears the first couple nights (from both child and parent!)– but with consistency, the issue may be resolved more quickly. If you find yourself debating the best way to negotiate a transition with your kids, evaluate your situation, consult with your pediatrician, follow your instincts and your personal comfort level as a parent, and you’ll make the right decision for your family.